Skip to main contentScroll Top

Scientific Error, Wrongful Convictions and Article 21: Rethinking the Right to a Fair Trial in India

Scientific Error, Wrongful Convictions and Article 21: Rethinking the Right to a Fair Trial in India

Author's Details -

Bipasa Pramanik (Haldia Law College, Haldia, India)

Received 15 September 2026; Accepted 15 October 2026; Published 19 October 2026

Cite this Paper: Bipasa Pramanik, 'Scientific Error, Wrongful Convictions and Article 21: Rethinking the Right to a Fair Trial in India' (2026) 7(1) Jus Corpus Law Journal 521-537 <https://doi.org/10.66918/juscorpus.v7i1.2026.38>

Category: Long Article

Pagination: 521-537

From ancient times to the present, forensic science has become an integral part of criminal cases in India, as courts rely on DNA profiling, ballistics, computer forensics, and other scientific methods to establish criminal liability. However, scientific reliability, proper evidence collection and preservation, and the objectivity of expert opinion may impact the evidentiary value of forensic evidence. Contamination, chain of custody violations, methodology flaws, cognitive biases, as well as inflated expert conclusions could even cause wrongful convictions. This article analyses the constitutional implications of forensic reliability with respect to Article 21 of the Constitution of India, which provides a guarantee of the ‘Right to a fair trial.’ It identifies the real absence of a thorough legal framework for evaluating forensic reliability. Using a doctrinal and analytical approach, this research examines the statutes, Supreme Court cases, and comparative approaches in relation to forensic reliability, and suggests measures that can effectively prevent wrongful convictions. It highlights that the forensic evidence originating from an accredited laboratory should not always be considered authoritative evidence unless its validity, integrity, interpretation, and evidentiary limitations are carefully examined. Incorporating the use of comparative analysis based on the Daubert Standard set in the United States, this article suggests a system of testing judicial reliability, quality-control and accreditation measures for labs, presentation of relevant forensic documents, independent oversight, and training of judges in this area. Finally, this article argues that strengthening all of these safeguards are necessary to avoid miscarriage of justice and for proper assessment of forensic evidence in conformity with the fundamental right, especially the right to a fair trial guaranteed by Article 21.
Paper Type Journal Info Creative Commons Copyright

Long Article

Jus Corpus Law Journal

Vol 7 Issue 1

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

© Jus Corpus Law Journal 2026

All rights reserved.