Skip to main contentScroll Top

‘Game of Skill’ to Blanket Prohibition: Examining the Constitutional Validity of India’s 2025 Online Gaming Regulatory Framework

‘Game of Skill’ to Blanket Prohibition: Examining the Constitutional Validity of India’s 2025 Online Gaming Regulatory Framework

Authors Details -

Chimmiri Susmitha (KL University, Guntur, India) & Dr. Pooja B. Sudharma (Assistant Professor, KL University, Guntur, India)

Received 19 September 2026; Accepted 20 October 2026; Published 24 October 2026

Cite this Paper: Chimmiri Susmitha & Dr. Pooja B. Sudharma, '‘Game of Skill’ to Blanket Prohibition: Examining the Constitutional Validity of India’s 2025 Online Gaming Regulatory Framework' (2026) 7(1) Jus Corpus Law Journal 590-611 <https://doi.org/10.66918/juscorpus.v7i1.2026.42>

Category: Long Article

Pagination: 590-611

The Promotion of Online Gaming and Regulation of the Game Act, 2025 (PROGA) is a departure from almost 70 years of Indian Jurisprudence on the classification of online games as games of skill versus games of chance for constitutional purposes. In State of Bombay v R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala (1957) skill predominant activity was held to be a proper trade under Article 19(1)(g) of PROGA, which has a blanket prohibition on any real money game, across the country. The main thrust of this paper is a constitutional analysis of the shift, which argues that the old skill/chance doctrine is not applicable here because it was the position taken by the Supreme Court in State of Tamil Nadu v Junglee Games India Pvt. Ltd. (2026) when determining that a game where money/stakes are bet on an uncertain outcome, which is predominantly a skill game, is a ‘betting and gambling’ under Entry 34 of the State List. The paper concludes that the primary constitutional concerns raised by PROGA have now been solved by the well-established concept of a difference between games of skill and games of chance in Article 19(1)(g) and that this is therefore an outdated approach to the constitutionality of online gambling. Contrary to this, the federalism aspect of the law’s constitutionality, the extent of delegating classificatory authority to the executive, and the proportionality of the regulatory system as per Article 21 are more significant. The paper further contends that a harmreduction, licensing system approach, one that is used by various countries in the world, would have been a better option for Parliament to consider. The fact that such alternatives have not received attention is especially relevant in the context of the necessity limb of the proportionality review.
Paper Type Journal Info Creative Commons Copyright

Long Article

Jus Corpus Law Journal

Vol 7 Issue 1

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

© Jus Corpus Law Journal 2026

All rights reserved.